Finding A Job You’ll Love: Recruiters

Ah recruiters. If you understand their motivations and find a good one, they can work wonders. But the average and bad ones can be worse than searching yourself.

When looking for a job, you should definitely search on your own through websites like and But you should also work with a recruiter. They can find jobs that you wouldn’t find, that aren’t even listed. And what’s more, they can help you understand how employers will view your resume, and when talking to companies they can help explain away any red flags. They can sometimes even give good career advice, if you know how to filter what they say.

The key to working with recruiters is to understand their motives. They’re middle men who are paid by commission, like used car salesmen and real estate agents. They’re paid by the company that hires you, and are paid 1 – 3 months of your salary, as far as I can tell in Boston.

You might think that, because their commission will go up if your starting salary goes up, they’ll negotiate a good one for you. But even if they negotiate a $5k/yr increase, they’ll only see ~ $1k of that. If they spend that time finding someone else a job, they’ll get a whole other commission, ~ $10k+.

So they try to close as many deals as possible and ignore the quality of each deal. To maximize their income, the bad ones will rush you into the first employer that will hire you. They also spend as little time on each deal as possible, and generally just do keyword matching: “This job requires XML, and you have XML on your resume, so it’s a match!”

The good ones will want to cultivate a long term relationship with both you and the companies they work for. But keep in mind, even good recruiters are generally non technical and don’t understand any of those acronyms. And both good and bad recruiters will only get you an offer from a single company, which really reduces your ability to negotiate.

Plus, each recruiter only represents a fraction of companies in your city. Google, for example, doesn’t work with any recruiters. So you always want to search on your own, even if you’re using a recruiter.

When you first talk to a recruiter, describe what you liked and didn’t like about past jobs. Then ask them for career advice: what sort of job do you think I’d enjoy? At what sort of company? What’s a possible career track for me for the next 10-20 years? Why? Listen to their thought process. The bad (including average) recruiters won’t have thought about such things, so they’ll say something generic. Treat them like another job web site: they’ll send you job ads and that’s about it.

How do you find a good recruiter? The best way is probably to ask your friends and co-workers. If you post your resume on job web sites, they’ll contact you, and you can try the test above to see if they’re any good.

In the end, the best strategy is to look for jobs yourself and work with a good recruiter. Just make sure that you do a thorough search on your own before you talk to a recruiter. One of the first thing’s they’ll ask you is what companies you’ve applied to. Once you give them that list, if you discover a company they work with, you need to go through them.

This entry was posted in Brain Rental. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Finding A Job You’ll Love: Recruiters

  1. Recruiters for entry level – mid level positions are usually the types you want to shy away from. They’re new to the gig and are not trusted to handle the larger accounts. If you’re going for the Sr. level position – management then a recruiter is a good choice for you. Especially when it comes to relocation. A good recruitment company will help out, they usually already have connections with realtors in the area because they’ve relocated others before.

  2. Sure a used car salesman can sell you a car. But you will most likely get ripped off if you do not know what you are doing. You will also feel a bit slimy working with the used car salesman.

    Recruiters are just the same. You know you can get a car with dealing with used car salesmen. Why not do the same and skip the recruiters?

  3. Pingback: Martin C. Martin » Finding A Job You’ll Love: Locating Opportunities

  4. Pingback: Martin C. Martin » Finding A Job You’ll Love: Negotiating An Offer

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s